Discover and read the best of Twitter Threads about #Soctwitter
Most recents (19)
Hello #soctwitter & etc, if you're planning a first-day-of-class (or etc) introductions, and you want to be inclusive of trans/non-binary folks, can I suggest (as a trans professor with a lot of trans & non-binary students) including pronouns as *optional* rather than required?
+
+
Pronouns in go-rounds & on name-tags & etc are great in many ways, bc they signal "we don't assume anyone's gender identity/pronouns here" and also "we're trying to be inclusive of trans & non-binary people."
BUT they're also deeply uncomfortable for anyone not ready to share.
BUT they're also deeply uncomfortable for anyone not ready to share.
I would have hated hated hated them when I was a not-yet-out-as-trans college student, and when I've made pronoun-sharing optional & explained why, I've gotten a lot of appreciation from my trans & NB students.
I also dislike them now, though I appreciate the intent a lot.
I also dislike them now, though I appreciate the intent a lot.
A list of required/recommended* readings on race/ism and white supremacy from my courses (cont.) #SocAF #SocTwitter #AcademicTwitter
A 🧵(sorted by theme):
A 🧵(sorted by theme):
Readings on #Whiteness & #WhiteSupremacy
White Rage: The Unspoken Truth of Our Racial Divide-@ProfCAnderson
"Whiteness as Property” in Harvard Law Review-Cheryl Harris
The Invention of the White Race, Volumes 1 & 2- Theodore Allen
White Rage: The Unspoken Truth of Our Racial Divide-@ProfCAnderson
"Whiteness as Property” in Harvard Law Review-Cheryl Harris
The Invention of the White Race, Volumes 1 & 2- Theodore Allen
The White Racial Frame: Centuries of Racial Framing and Counter-Framing-@JoeFeagin
White Women, Race Matters: The Social Construction of Whiteness-Ruth Frankenberg
White Kids: Growing Up with Privilege in a Racially Divided America-@MaggieHagerman
White Women, Race Matters: The Social Construction of Whiteness-Ruth Frankenberg
White Kids: Growing Up with Privilege in a Racially Divided America-@MaggieHagerman
A list of required/recommended* readings on race/ism and white supremacy from my courses, as promised. Feel free to add more. #SocAF #SocTwitter #AcademicTwitter
*Diff based on access and affordability for my students, but they're all good options.
A 🧵(sorted by theme):
*Diff based on access and affordability for my students, but they're all good options.
A 🧵(sorted by theme):
On Scientific Racism, Past and Present:
The Mismeasure of Man. -Stephen Gould
The Emperor’s New Clothes: Biological Theories of Race at the Millennium-Joseph Graves, Jr. @gravesjl55
The Myth of Race: The Troubling Persistence of an Unscientific Idea-Robert Sussman
The Mismeasure of Man. -Stephen Gould
The Emperor’s New Clothes: Biological Theories of Race at the Millennium-Joseph Graves, Jr. @gravesjl55
The Myth of Race: The Troubling Persistence of an Unscientific Idea-Robert Sussman
Killing the Black Body: Race, Reproduction, and the Meaning of Liberty / Fatal Invention: How Science, Politics, and Big Business Re-Create Race in the Twenty-First Century-@DorothyERoberts
Race Unmasked: Biology and Race in the 20th Century-Michael Yudell @PublicsHealth
Race Unmasked: Biology and Race in the 20th Century-Michael Yudell @PublicsHealth
THEORIZING PART #2
Given the interest in my previous thread, I decided to follow up with 12 additional resources on theorizing.
I've also included selected community suggestions from the previous thread.
Buckle up! 🧵⬇️
#AcademicTwitter #soctwitter
Given the interest in my previous thread, I decided to follow up with 12 additional resources on theorizing.
I've also included selected community suggestions from the previous thread.
Buckle up! 🧵⬇️
#AcademicTwitter #soctwitter
BOOKS
Swedberg - Theorizing in Social Science
An anthology and follow-up to 'Art of Social Theory'. Includes chapters by key thinkers such as Karen Knorr-Cetina, Diane Vaughan, Stephen Turner, Karl Weick and James March.
degruyter.com/document/doi/1…
Swedberg - Theorizing in Social Science
An anthology and follow-up to 'Art of Social Theory'. Includes chapters by key thinkers such as Karen Knorr-Cetina, Diane Vaughan, Stephen Turner, Karl Weick and James March.
degruyter.com/document/doi/1…
Reed - Interpretation and Social Knowledge
A highly ambitious work in which Reed demonstrates how to construct 'maximal interpretations' - that is, historically specific and hermeneutically rich explanations of social phenomena
press.uchicago.edu/ucp/books/book…
A highly ambitious work in which Reed demonstrates how to construct 'maximal interpretations' - that is, historically specific and hermeneutically rich explanations of social phenomena
press.uchicago.edu/ucp/books/book…
Sociology has seen increased interest in *theorizing*: the practical work of developing theory.
Having recently immersed myself in this literature, I decided to make a list of 20 of my favorite publications🧵⬇️
#SocTwitter #AcademicTwitter
Having recently immersed myself in this literature, I decided to make a list of 20 of my favorite publications🧵⬇️
#SocTwitter #AcademicTwitter
BOOKS
Swedberg - The Art of Social Theory
The most obvious reference on this list. Discusses every aspect of theorizing, from observation and naming to concept formation and explanation
press.princeton.edu/books/hardcove…
Swedberg - The Art of Social Theory
The most obvious reference on this list. Discusses every aspect of theorizing, from observation and naming to concept formation and explanation
press.princeton.edu/books/hardcove…
Tavory & Timmermans - Abductive Analysis
Lays out the epistemological and methodological basis for 'abductive analysis', one of the more exciting approaches to theory-development
press.uchicago.edu/ucp/books/book…
Lays out the epistemological and methodological basis for 'abductive analysis', one of the more exciting approaches to theory-development
press.uchicago.edu/ucp/books/book…
#soctwitter & #poliscitwitter - if you're teaching something of mine this fall, I will very happily Zoom into your class (or come in person if possible). I try to make most things I write, and all my speaking, accessible to & engaging for undergrads & everyone else. Some ideas:
I would LOVE it if folks teaching American Politics, Campaigns & Elections, Political Sociology & etc use some or all of Producing Politics. It's got:
- an accessible overview of what we know about campaign effects (ch 1)
- discussion inequalities in pol participation (all thru)+
- an accessible overview of what we know about campaign effects (ch 1)
- discussion inequalities in pol participation (all thru)+
- insights into what campaigns actually do & what it's like to be on one (all thru, but especially ch 2)
- discussion of the campaign staff "revolving door" & of where they go outside campaigns (ch 6)
& lots more, in a short affordable book. bit.ly/ProducingPolit…
- discussion of the campaign staff "revolving door" & of where they go outside campaigns (ch 6)
& lots more, in a short affordable book. bit.ly/ProducingPolit…
Was asked to review this but have been putting it off. I am more worried about what it will say about me as a person and scholar than what I have to say about it. But I need a break this morning so here I go.
#soctwitter #BookTwitter #bookreview #bellah
#soctwitter #BookTwitter #bookreview #bellah
Enjoying this biography of Bellah by Matteo Bortolini of the U of Padua. It's very well written for a sociologist, much less one who I assume is not a native English speaker. It is a full biography not just an intellectual biography.
TIL: Bellah's father abandoned his family and committed suicide, leading him to be renamed Robert Neeley. He was a competitive individualist in HS. And he served a year in the Army after he arrived at Harvard.
@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @rjcsmith @Edsall @Musa_alGharbi @SenWhitehouse @DouthatNYT Insightful @DouthatNYT, approaching that #KnowledgeCulturalSociology in which we ask how to name global transformations nytimes.com/2022/02/26/opi… Better to go 1 more step: does this Huntington revision risk legitimating the evil Putin, Modi, et al rain down on "their" peoples? Yes.
@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @rjcsmith @Edsall @Musa_alGharbi @SenWhitehouse @DouthatNYT More #KnowledgeCulturalSociology on naming our epoch: Closer than @DouthatNYT (above), Ivan Krastev nytimes.com/2022/02/27/opi… evokes Enzensberger - "violence has freed itself from ideology". At least it has for Putin. After Putin's defeat, may we retreat from his special Hell.
@BrownUniversity @BrownSociology @SwearerCenter @pubstory @tompharvard @JMLudes @gwaynemiller @jseelybrown @Morning_Joe @costareports @juliaf113 @khaila__ @KBAndersen @dlittle30 @kimberlykhoang @TomPerez @WatsonInstitute @robert_a_blair @craigjcalhoun @nyu_ipk @ikaribjanian @nkwarikoo @chinyereagbai @ohahl @ASR_Journal @bartbonikowski @UMich @toddgitlin @SlaterPolitics @umichWCED @engagedscholar @DYStateofMind @emmaschow @alex_s_cramer @craigmelvin @billpeduto @peterbakernyt @GlennKesslerWP @CharlesMBlow @neal_katyal @gtconway3d @pareene @FEPS_Europe @vivienaschmidt @rjcsmith @Edsall @Musa_alGharbi @SenWhitehouse More naming our epoch by @damiencave nytimes.com/2022/03/04/wor… declaring response to Putin in Ukraine its switch. @BorisJohnson authors the heroic role every leader believing in #UKRSovereignty ought. nytimes.com/2022/03/06/opi… But in action? Will speech be prologue? Or substitute?
#soctwitter, I am reviewing an interesting paper using qual interviews. The authors often count statements etc (eg half stated x) to indicate salience. Yet the sample is not a random one. How am I to think about this (as an absolute non-expert on qual)?
Perhaps @JessicaCalarco @MarioLuisSmall would be able to give me some clues. Just saw that a book on qual literacy is forthcoming - I would be the first to buy that!
@threadreaderapp unroll
As some know, I teach a publishing course for grad students focused on articles. Here is some common feedback that I give on student drafts #SocTwitter: (1) The "lit review" needs an argument. The section should not be about "here's how widely read I am in topic X," but about 1/
"here's my argument about the prior literature that THIS paper addresses." This doesn't have to be a gap, but can be. (2) The front of the paper doesn't match the back end. That is, the paper sets up expectations for answers to questions that the data cannot answer. This often 2/
has to do with writing order or reusing proposals that describe the work for intro material. BUT can also be because the paper is a piece of a larger project and the front end talks too much about the larger context in ways that are not needed for the specific paper (common in 3/
So thrilled to receive my copy of @SarahDamaske’s The Tolls of Uncertainty. I had the privilege of reading drafts of this book and I whole heartedly recommend it for family, inequality, labor, and gender classes. @PrincetonUPress #AcademicTwitter #soctwitter 1/7
Damaske’s book shows how the experience of unemployment, including the job loss, its consequences, the search for new work, and subsequent employment, are shaped by gender & class. As a consequence, gender & class inequalities are exacerbated by the unemployment process. 2/7
Women feel guilt for their job losses and make it up by sacrificing their health and wellbeing for their families and taking on extra household labor while men (particularly middle-class men) feel empowered to take time for themselves. 3/7
Sharing my comments on grant-writing (esp as scholar working at non-R1). Kudos to @mignon_moore & @mjonescorrea for organizing such supportive, informative conference. Apply to #PDSI_RSF next year! #soctwitter
- Your priority is to obtain tenure!
- Grants generate revenue for institutions. U may be pressured to chase grants but publications secure u tenure & applying for grants take time away from publishing
- Grant writing is riskier, higher stakes than article writing
- Grants generate revenue for institutions. U may be pressured to chase grants but publications secure u tenure & applying for grants take time away from publishing
- Grant writing is riskier, higher stakes than article writing
There is a sweet spot for grant writing
- Too early: u don't have the body of work to be considered an expert
- Too late: why fund project if it is near completion?
- Eary juniors (<3yrs): seed grants, smaller grant geared toward junior scholars (i.e. RSF presidential awards)
- Too early: u don't have the body of work to be considered an expert
- Too late: why fund project if it is near completion?
- Eary juniors (<3yrs): seed grants, smaller grant geared toward junior scholars (i.e. RSF presidential awards)
1/ Why is "framing" and lit review so contentious in sociology? A thread for #soctwitter and assorted bystanders.
2/ Last week, our department had a very nice panel where faculty answered questions publishing. Panel included current/former editors/deputy editors of ASR, AJS, Contexts, Soc of Ed, SPQ and more. (Yes, our dept is super professional and service oriented).
3/ Most advice was simple and intuitive: keep revising, show your work, read the journal you submit to, take rejection in stride, accept the randomness of reviews, etc. BUT the discussion of framing and lit review was long and complex.
My new article "On Track or Derailed? Race, Advanced Math, and the Transition to High School" in @SociusJournal summarized in tweet form.
A thread:
#Sociology #Soctwitter #mathequity #BlackandSTEM
journals.sagepub.com/doi/full/10.11…
A thread:
#Sociology #Soctwitter #mathequity #BlackandSTEM
journals.sagepub.com/doi/full/10.11…
Taking advanced math in HS influences academic success, what careers we pursue, and how much $ we make. Studies find racial gaps in who takes Calculus in HS & Algebra I in MS, but there is little research on race and adv math course taking during the transition to HS. 2/
This study uses national data to examine adv math course taking in 9th grade for students on the accelerated track who took Alg I+ in 8th grade and students on the standard track who took <Alg I. I also look at the role of performance factors & parents, teachers & counselors 3/
Very proud of the best mentor ever. Well deserved! /Muy orgullosa del mejor mentor que pude tener. Muy merecido este premio. #soctwitter John Markoff nos ha ayudado a entender mejor la historia de la democracia y el rol de los movimientos sociales en ella.
Su libro, Olas de Democracia, da una explicación dinámica de la democracia, que va cambiando, en la que hay múltiples actores. Ahí, Markoff desafía miradas fijas y solo institucionales de la democracia. amazon.com/Olas-democraci… 2/n
Su libro sobre los campesinos en la Revolución Francesa, desafía la idea de una revolución construida solo desde las elites. Es además, un ejemplo de análisis de contenido y de uso de fuentes históricas para la sociología. amazon.es/Abolition-Feud… 3/n
Just had this thought after conversing with some fellow Black colleagues in academe about hostility we have (and continue to) face on the job. So, to my Black fam in academe, many of you work in units where the knees of white supremacy are constantly on your necks. They put...
put their knees on your necks because they know the structure in academe encourages and incentivizes anti-Blackness. Yet, some of those culprits who dare seek to block your joy and contribution will attempt to send calls of action to your unit listservs, etc., demanding...
that your dept makes a statement, or etc. Understand, you’re duty-bound to reject these overtures – they’re insincere and phony #NotWithMyName. Especially if these colleagues have yet to repent. Again, #NotWithMyName! Sometimes all we have left is our dignity, and we should...
1/12 How does #Demography impact #COVID19 deaths? In new pre-print, we illustrate how older population age structure can interact with high mortality rates at older ages to produce a large # of fatalities, as in Italy. osf.io/se6wy/?view_on… #poptwitter #epitwitter
2/12 #COVID19 fatalities are hitting older age groups hard. Case fatality rates for 80-90 currently 17.5% in Italy. While these numbers will hopefully be overestimates, the burden on older ages groups is frighteningly high.
3/12 With current concentration of deaths at older ages, COVID-19 deaths will hit older countries hard (Italy has 23% of population >65). Figure 1 compares Italy to South Korea (top) and Nigeria to Brazil (bottom) – two countries similar in size but different age distributions.
I need help: A friend is meeting with some teachers to discuss racial inequalities in middle and high school. They would like to have some studies ready to show the teachers the inequalities minority kids, esp. black boys, face in schools.
I'll be doing a search on my own, but would love the insight of experts who could point to 2-3 studies that make this point really well. Or to strategies that help teachers do better for minority students in these situations.
Thanks so much for any help!!!
#soctwitter @ASAnews
Thanks so much for any help!!!
#soctwitter @ASAnews
Rejection letters & harsh reviews are wack, but they almost always provide us with clues on how to get better. Here’s a quick thread with some ways of dealing with rejection. 👊 #SocTwitter #AcademicTwitter #phdchat 1
Before I even click on the PDF containing reviewer comments, I tell myself a little mantra that is huge in jiu jitsu: “You either win or your learn. There is no losing.” It sounds hokey, but this mantra has helped me appreciate very critical reviews #SocTwitter #AcademicTwitter
Then, while reading reviewer comments, I look for the “fatal flaws” that got my work canned. Usually the issue is about theory choice, methods, or a mismatch between theory / data. I don’t get mired in little stuff...yet... #SocTwitter #AcademicTwitter #phdchat 3
