Discover and read the best of Twitter Threads about #keirabell
Most recents (24)
THREAD Yesterday Miriam Cates MP alongside @RosieDuffield1 @JackieDP secured an #RSEDebate. Opening speech here “The internet presents children with a vast array of false & damaging information about sex” #SafeguardingDisaster
Many of the #SafeguardingFail s we have hi-lighted over the past few years were included, alongside concerns raised by groups @Transgendertrd @BayswaterSG @ParentsForED @FamEdTrust. If you are new to these shocking failures we have links to further info on the cases mentioned.
BISH & School of Sexuality were mentioned, they both feature in our parents guide to #RSE & #PSHE (school of sexuality was previously sexplain) #edutwitter safeschoolsallianceuk.net/wp-content/upl…
Thread. #KeiraBell
There was nothing wrong with my body - #KeiraBell womansplaceuk.org/2020/11/30/kei…
WPUK position on Gillick/Fraser guidelines womansplaceuk.org/2020/10/11/wpu…
Did you know you can sue your health professionals on this basis: Standards of Care WPATH (v7, 2012) clause that "role of mental health professionals includes making reasonably sure that gender dysphoria is not secondary to or better accounted for by other diagnoses".
If your health professionals failed to diagnose your Autism, Aspergers, ADHD, trauma, sexual abuse, trauma, family violence, etc., and diagnosed your Gender dysphoria as primary, rather than secondary 👉 HIRE a lawyer, DM me or email me please
Given the emphasis in psychologists education and training on evidence based research methodology and science, argument that were is particularly problematic for psychologists. @austpsych and psychologists will argue its popular opinion to medicalise children. That argument
👉🏻 ANNOUNCING AUSTRALIA’S FIRST #DETRANS Gender Clinic to open soon! There is a great need #aus clinics to provide specialist therapy, group therapy, Support, referrals, resources, research, current law, books to #australian clients of all ages #trans #detrans #gender #Australia
The clinic aims to have highly trained and specialist therapists who will provide specialist trauma therapy to clients of all ages who are in the various stages of detransitioning and/or gender dysphoria.
The clinic specialists will have experience training Ed. in (or be willing to) GD, ASD (female autism as it presents), ADHD, #essences, child development, highest Ethics & safeguarding principals, trauma & C-PTSD, abuse, sexual abuse, differential dx, Gillick informed consent
Australian Judges to now oversee #transgender #teen treatment is a positive step forward and welcomed in order to safeguard children who are unable to give full #gillick #informedconsent theaustralian.com.au/nation/judges-…
Thank you @KLBfax for your #bravery and standing up for vulnerable children who deserve #safeguarding, should have been given full #gillick informed consent and should have had their immature prefrontal cortex, as a consequence of child development, taken into consideration
“Supporting trans pupils in school” from @JustLikeUsUK for #SchoolDiversityWeek
They state ‘do not share this document with staff outside of your school’. We wonder why?
Is it because it undermines #safeguarding? Breaches guidance & law or says biological sex is a spectrum?
They state ‘do not share this document with staff outside of your school’. We wonder why?
Is it because it undermines #safeguarding? Breaches guidance & law or says biological sex is a spectrum?
#SchoolDiversityWeek promotion of puberty blockers taking no account of #KeiraBell ruling. Repeated conflation of sex with gender.
#WomenEd #Teachertwitter #edutwitter
#WomenEd #Teachertwitter #edutwitter
More misrepresentations of the law and undermining of #safeguarding from @justlikeus for #SchoolDiversity week. Advising hiding of child’s sex & mixed sex facilities, leaving schools open to legal action.
#edutwitter #WomenEd #Teachertwitter
#edutwitter #WomenEd #Teachertwitter
IRELAND: In 2007 the Ombudsman for Children @OCO_ireland had formed very strong opinions on what would be in children’s best interest regarding gender Identity and transitioning & GRA
A thread with screen shots taken from...
1/
oco.ie/app/uploads/20…
opensocietyfoundations.org/uploads/a958c0…
A thread with screen shots taken from...
1/
oco.ie/app/uploads/20…
opensocietyfoundations.org/uploads/a958c0…
2/ and these documents oco.ie/app/uploads/20…
gov.ie/en/consultatio…
gov.ie/pdf/?file=http…
gov.ie/pdf/?file=http…
assets.gov.ie/42465/8abfc775…
gov.ie/en/consultatio…
gov.ie/pdf/?file=http…
gov.ie/pdf/?file=http…
assets.gov.ie/42465/8abfc775…
3/ Dealing with the first link first- this is the submission from OCO “Advice on the General Scheme of the Gender Recognition Bill 2013”. This was the proposed medical model Bill which was passed in the Seanad and then changed to self ID when it reached the Dáil.
What actually happened is Levine was repeatedly asked whether Levine was for or against **minors** receiving hormones and/or surgeries without parental consent. Levine refused to answer the question. Repeatedly.
Rachel Levine could become US Assistant Sec. of Health. Paul cited the #KeiraBell case, quoting Bell directly: "I made a brash decision as a teenager, as a lot of teenagers do. Trying to find competence & happiness, except now the rest of my life will be negatively affected."
The @CareQualityComm inspection report which found @TaviAndPort #GIDS service to be ‘inadequate’ is a truly shocking read. We are appalled at the spin that this is just about waiting times. It is not. This is a #safeguarding scandal. Full report here:
api.cqc.org.uk/public/v1/repo…
api.cqc.org.uk/public/v1/repo…
Questions must be asked (and answered) about why so many children were experiencing distress around gender in the first place. What has gone wrong in our society? Why are we failing to challenge gender stereotypes? What are children looking at online?
#edutwitter #safeguarding
#edutwitter #safeguarding
The regulatory capture in our society has gone so far that even the @CareQualityComm report into this scandal uses highly contested, ideological language such as ‘assigned sex at birth’. This must stop. Sex is observed at birth, usually by medical professionals.
#SexMatters
#SexMatters
"A live experiment on adolescents and children."
'We have left established evidence-based clinical practice and are using powerful life-altering medication for a vulnerable group of adolescents and children based upon a belief."
#KeiraBell
dailymail.co.uk/news/article-9…
'We have left established evidence-based clinical practice and are using powerful life-altering medication for a vulnerable group of adolescents and children based upon a belief."
#KeiraBell
dailymail.co.uk/news/article-9…
Extracts from evidence submitted in support of Transgender Trend's intervention.
#KeiraBell
#detransition
#KeiraBell
#detransition
1/ So, so many emotions this morning. Relief & anger amongst them: just imagine if that crowd storming the Capitol was Black.
Never thought I’d be grateful for @VP Mike Pence - but I am. He gave one of the finest speeches of any politician last night.
Never thought I’d be grateful for @VP Mike Pence - but I am. He gave one of the finest speeches of any politician last night.
2/ But most of all, despite everything that happened overnight in the US, I never thought I’d feel fear about a Democratic president, with control of both Houses of Congress - but I do.
3/ I’m a Democrat. I’m also a Black British feminist & a lesbian. I believe that sex is real & immutable. I believe passionately that gender-diverse & transgender persons must be protected from discrimination, but not at the cost of erasing ’woman’ as a sex based legal category.
Max was 11 years old and Ash was 8. Their stories were told in the 2016 documentary on the Tavistock GIDS clinic “Kids on the Edge: the Gender Clinic”. The clinic’s management was delighted with the documentary. Its director, Dr Polly Carmichael, said enthusiastically:/1of12
”We all feel proud to have been involved in the process and that we could not have wished for more in the way that they approached and conducted the whole process.”/2of12
Peter Beard, for the Guardian, enthused in his review: “I hope the people who rage about such things might also find the time to watch The Gender Clinic, which does a steady job of dismantling many of the panicked, inaccurate fears around what is clearly a complex process.”/3of12
What a wk!
Here's a thread to warm hearts -
Clips of our signatories @JohannLamont @JennyMarra @ProfAliceS @Docstockk @GoonerProf & Lord Young of Norwood Green in action @UKHouseofLords @Commonswomequ & @ScotParl,
& @LabWomenDec webinar
#SexNotGender
youtube.com/channel/UCQRGV…
1/8
Here's a thread to warm hearts -
Clips of our signatories @JohannLamont @JennyMarra @ProfAliceS @Docstockk @GoonerProf & Lord Young of Norwood Green in action @UKHouseofLords @Commonswomequ & @ScotParl,
& @LabWomenDec webinar
#SexNotGender
youtube.com/channel/UCQRGV…
1/8
Here's the mighty @scottishlabour MSP @JohannLamont opening the debate on Thursday for her amendment -
"For the word ‘gender’ substitute ‘sex’ "
to the Forensic Medical Services Bill (Scotland)
#SixWords
#SexNotGender
2/8
"For the word ‘gender’ substitute ‘sex’ "
to the Forensic Medical Services Bill (Scotland)
#SixWords
#SexNotGender
2/8
Here's @JohannLamont's unforgettable closing speech in that debate.
The amendment was passed by a landslide majority.
Just 9 against (Libdems and Greens).
#SixWords
#SexNotGender
3/8
The amendment was passed by a landslide majority.
Just 9 against (Libdems and Greens).
#SixWords
#SexNotGender
3/8
Thread on Meeting 15 by the Standing Committee on Justice and Human Rights
Watch it live or stream it later here:
parlvu.parl.gc.ca/Harmony/en/Pow…
Watch it live or stream it later here:
parlvu.parl.gc.ca/Harmony/en/Pow…
We had been invited by @LDBildy of @JCCFCanada to share her time today, but we were not allowed to participate at the last minute.
Lisa Bildy incorporated some of our most salient concerns in her statement to the committee, and we are very grateful for that.
Lisa Bildy incorporated some of our most salient concerns in her statement to the committee, and we are very grateful for that.
Ah. Philip Pullman has allegedly never heard of Rachel Rooney.
With this, I will now update the Philip Pullman status from "being disingenuous" to "lying through his teeth".
Demonstration to follow.
Demonstration to follow.
1) Clara Vulliamy vaguely states she's going to say something personal. No further details.
2) Pullman replies that he supports her "in this matter".
And he refers to "hateful voices". Clearly, he already knows what she's going to be talking about.
2) Pullman replies that he supports her "in this matter".
And he refers to "hateful voices". Clearly, he already knows what she's going to be talking about.
Thread on the #keirabell judgement and sorry state of evidence-lead health policy in New Zealand.
We have further confirmation that there is no good evidence of benefit from puberty blockers, and significant risks.
1/11
We have further confirmation that there is no good evidence of benefit from puberty blockers, and significant risks.
1/11
The judges heard evidence for and against, and testimony from former patients. They ruled that puberty blocking is "experimental", with "very limited evidence as to its efficacy"
An unsurprising finding if you're familiar with the literature.
2/11
An unsurprising finding if you're familiar with the literature.
2/11
This is a continuation of the findings from the national health body reviews from Sweden and Finland. Both find that evidence is insufficient.
3/11
segm.org/UK_HighCourt_R…
3/11
segm.org/UK_HighCourt_R…
This is a bizarre & wholly wrong condemnation of the young #KeiraBell, who was badly advised, allowed to go through unnecessary surgery & medical treatment, & who now points out how badly advised she was.
Yes, #KeiraBell *dared* to go to court to protest malpractice and bad advice. Too bad if you don't like that, the UK still manages to be somewhere where a person can go to court to redress wrongs. Suck it up, get over it.
I still can't get over the other tweeter who wanted Biden to go in and muscle the UK into ignoring its own High Court judgment. I mean, seriously, what planet are people living on?
THREAD
We have been sent these screenshots from a Facebook group of teachers unofficially affiliated with a major union.
We are disturbed to see this misinformation and lack of understanding of safeguarding being circulated.
We have been sent these screenshots from a Facebook group of teachers unofficially affiliated with a major union.
We are disturbed to see this misinformation and lack of understanding of safeguarding being circulated.
We agree that it is important for school staff to be mindful of any trans-identified student in their care, suffering from mental distress (or any students experiencing mental distress for whatever reason).
We understand that the #KeiraBell case will have caused distress to some, especially given the dangerous narrative being irresponsibly pushed that this will make children suicidal and was an attack on their rights, not an action to safeguard and protect them.
The UK High Court rules that #PubertyBlockers for normally-timed puberty are experimental and that young gender-dysphoric people (under 16) are unlikely to be able to provide meaningful informed consent.
Read SEGM's full statement below:
segm.org/UK_HighCourt_R…
#KeiraBell
/1
Read SEGM's full statement below:
segm.org/UK_HighCourt_R…
#KeiraBell
/1
It is not yet known whether there is long-term psychological harm or benefit, whether suicide rates are increased, decreased or unchanged, and whether blockers contribute to longer-term persistence of gender dysphoria and adverse impacts on future morbidity and mortality. /2
Ethical practitioners must humbly recognize the significant uncertainties in the field of gender medicine. We hope that the Court's landmark judgement will mark the beginning of international commitment to generating quality evidence base for young people with #GenderDysphoria./3
Some commentators are saying the #KeiraBell judgment undermines Gillick. They're wrong. See this blog by @TybilAlper womansplaceuk.org/2020/11/29/wom… #IStandWithKeiraBell
“Some commentary on the case has argued that a win for Bell presents a risk to Gillick competence, which governs circumstances in which children have capacity to consent to medical treatment & to Fraser guidelines, which set out criteria for contraceptive advice & prescribing.”
“The argument before the court, however, is much narrower. It concerns whether informed consent can ever be gained given the specific nature of the treatment:
1/n On the #KieraBell court ruling. This is a UK High Court legal review that has been set in motion since January. Defendant: The Tavistock And Portman NHS Foundation Trust.
The NHS England also enters as "Interested Party".
theguardian.com/society/2020/j…
The NHS England also enters as "Interested Party".
theguardian.com/society/2020/j…
2/ One point here: the #Tavistock, & anybody who cared, have had since January to brush up their data, & their legal arguments, since January. *Plenty* of time.
It involves not just #KieraBell, but another, Mrs. A..
A good start to understanding:
womansplaceuk.org/2020/11/30/kei…
It involves not just #KieraBell, but another, Mrs. A..
A good start to understanding:
womansplaceuk.org/2020/11/30/kei…
3/ So what is the #KieraBell legal review case & ruling about?
The prescribing of puberty-suppressing meds to those under the age of 18 who experience #GenderDysphoria, by the #Tavistock, through its Gender Identity Development Service (GIDS).
judiciary.uk/wp-content/upl…
The prescribing of puberty-suppressing meds to those under the age of 18 who experience #GenderDysphoria, by the #Tavistock, through its Gender Identity Development Service (GIDS).
judiciary.uk/wp-content/upl…
Press statement from#KeiraBell (h/t @Belstaffie)
“These drugs seriously harmed me in more ways than one and they have harmed many more…particularly girls and young women.” 1/n
“These drugs seriously harmed me in more ways than one and they have harmed many more…particularly girls and young women.” 1/n
"I would like to personally call on professionals and clinicians to create better mental health services and models to help those dealing with gender dysphoria to reconcile with their sex. " 2/n #KeiraBell
"And furthermore I call on society to accept those who do not conform to sex stereotypes -- not push them into a life of drugs and concealment from who they truly are. This means stopping the homophobia, the misogyny and the bullying of those that are different.” 3/n #KeiraBell
From today’s judgement in the #KeiraBell case: “The third Intervener is @Transgendertrd, an organisation that provides evidence- based information & resources for parents & schools concerning children with GD. @cwknews is the director of that organisation...
she has filed a witness statement in these proceedings.
She set out concerns about the lack of evidence as to the impacts & effectiveness of PBs & in relation to which patients it is most likely to help. Much of her evidence focused on the increase of referrals to GIDS of...
She set out concerns about the lack of evidence as to the impacts & effectiveness of PBs & in relation to which patients it is most likely to help. Much of her evidence focused on the increase of referrals to GIDS of...
teenage natal girls & the cultural factors, including material on the internet & social media, which may play a part in this. She said that GIDS does not offer young people with GD a range of ways to interpret their experience, & the GIDS pathway offers a minimal challenge to...
We salute the bravery of #KeiraBell & Mrs A in bringing the case. We applaud years of hard work & high level research by Stephanie Davies-Arai @Transgendertrd. The importance of that work was recognised by @JudiciaryUK when TT were permitted to make an intervention at court 1/9
We quote: "The court granted Transgender Trend permission to intervene on the basis that we had introduced new evidence that was potentially relevant to the case. The submissions from both @stonewalluk & @Mermaids_Gender were judged on exactly the same grounds", 2/9
"and they were refused permission on the basis that they had either repeated evidence already before the court in witness statements, or that the evidence they submitted was irrelevant to the case". 3/9
